1 _ 2 _ __ _ __ ___ __ _ _ __ __ _ _ __ | |__ 3 | '_ \| '_ ` _ \ _____ / _` | '__/ _` | '_ \| '_ \ 4 | |_) | | | | | |_____| (_| | | | (_| | |_) | | | | 5 | .__/|_| |_| |_| \__, |_| \__,_| .__/|_| |_| 6 |_| |___/ |_| 7 8 pm-graph: suspend/resume/boot timing analysis tools 9 Version: 5.11 10 Author: Todd Brandt <todd.e.brandt@intel.com> 11 Home Page: https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/developer/topic-technology/open/pm-graph/overview.html 12 13 Report bugs/issues at bugzilla.kernel.org Tools/pm-graph 14 - https://bugzilla.kernel.org/buglist.cgi?component=pm-graph&product=Tools 15 16 Full documentation available online & in man pages 17 - Getting Started: 18 https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/developer/articles/technical/usage.html 19 20 - Feature Summary: 21 https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/developer/topic-technology/open/pm-graph/features.html 22 23 - upstream version in git: 24 git clone https://github.com/intel/pm-graph/ 25 26 Table of Contents 27 - Overview 28 - Setup 29 - Usage 30 - Basic Usage 31 - Dev Mode Usage 32 - Proc Mode Usage 33 - Endurance Testing 34 - Usage Examples 35 - Configuration Files 36 - Usage Examples 37 - Config File Options 38 - Custom Timeline Entries 39 - Adding/Editing Timeline Functions 40 - Adding/Editing Dev Timeline Source Functions 41 - Verifying your Custom Functions 42 - Testing on consumer linux Operating Systems 43 - Android 44 45 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 46 | OVERVIEW | 47 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 48 49 This tool suite is designed to assist kernel and OS developers in optimizing 50 their linux stack's suspend/resume & boot time. Using a kernel image built 51 with a few extra options enabled, the tools will execute a suspend or boot, 52 and will capture dmesg and ftrace data. This data is transformed into a set of 53 timelines and a callgraph to give a quick and detailed view of which devices 54 and kernel processes are taking the most time in suspend/resume & boot. 55 56 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 57 | SETUP | 58 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 59 60 Package Requirements 61 - runs with python2 or python3, choice is made by /usr/bin/python link 62 - python 63 - python-configparser (for python2 sleepgraph) 64 - python-requests (for stresstester.py) 65 - linux-tools-common (for turbostat usage in sleepgraph) 66 67 Ubuntu: 68 sudo apt-get install python python-configparser python-requests linux-tools-common 69 70 Fedora: 71 sudo dnf install python python-configparser python-requests linux-tools-common 72 73 The tools can most easily be installed via git clone and make install 74 75 $> git clone http://github.com/intel/pm-graph.git 76 $> cd pm-graph 77 $> sudo make install 78 $> man sleepgraph ; man bootgraph 79 80 Setup involves some minor kernel configuration 81 82 The following kernel build options are required for all kernels: 83 CONFIG_DEVMEM=y 84 CONFIG_PM_DEBUG=y 85 CONFIG_PM_SLEEP_DEBUG=y 86 CONFIG_FTRACE=y 87 CONFIG_FUNCTION_TRACER=y 88 CONFIG_FUNCTION_GRAPH_TRACER=y 89 CONFIG_KPROBES=y 90 CONFIG_KPROBES_ON_FTRACE=y 91 92 In kernel 3.15.0, two patches were upstreamed which enable the 93 v3.0 behavior. These patches allow the tool to read all the 94 data from trace events instead of from dmesg. You can enable 95 this behavior on earlier kernels with these patches: 96 97 (kernel/pre-3.15/enable_trace_events_suspend_resume.patch) 98 (kernel/pre-3.15/enable_trace_events_device_pm_callback.patch) 99 100 If you're using bootgraph, or sleepgraph with a kernel older than 3.15.0, 101 the following additional kernel parameters are required: 102 (e.g. in file /etc/default/grub) 103 GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX_DEFAULT="... initcall_debug log_buf_len=32M ..." 104 105 If you're using a kernel older than 3.11-rc2, the following simple 106 patch must be applied to enable ftrace data: 107 in file: kernel/power/suspend.c 108 in function: int suspend_devices_and_enter(suspend_state_t state) 109 remove call to "ftrace_stop();" 110 remove call to "ftrace_start();" 111 112 There is a patch which does this for kernel v3.8.0: 113 (kernel/pre-3.11-rc2/enable_ftrace_in_suspendresume.patch) 114 115 116 117 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 118 | USAGE | 119 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 120 121 Basic Usage 122 ___________ 123 124 1) First configure a kernel using the instructions from the previous sections. 125 Then build, install, and boot with it. 126 2) Open up a terminal window and execute the mode list command: 127 128 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -modes 129 ['freeze', 'mem', 'disk'] 130 131 Execute a test using one of the available power modes, e.g. mem (S3): 132 133 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -m mem -rtcwake 15 134 135 or with a config file 136 137 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -config config/suspend.cfg 138 139 When the system comes back you'll see the script finishing up and 140 creating the output files in the test subdir. It generates output 141 files in subdirectory: suspend-mmddyy-HHMMSS. The ftrace file can 142 be used to regenerate the html timeline with different options 143 144 HTML output: <hostname>_<mode>.html 145 raw dmesg output: <hostname>_<mode>_dmesg.txt 146 raw ftrace output: <hostname>_<mode>_ftrace.txt 147 148 View the html in firefox or chrome. 149 150 151 Dev Mode Usage 152 ______________ 153 154 Developer mode adds information on low level source calls to the timeline. 155 The tool sets kprobes on all delay and mutex calls to see which devices 156 are waiting for something and when. It also sets a suite of kprobes on 157 subsystem dependent calls to better fill out the timeline. 158 159 The tool will also expose kernel threads that don't normally show up in the 160 timeline. This is useful in discovering dependent threads to get a better 161 idea of what each device is waiting for. For instance, the scsi_eh thread, 162 a.k.a. scsi resume error handler, is what each SATA disk device waits for 163 before it can continue resume. 164 165 The timeline will be much larger if run with dev mode, so it can be useful 166 to set the -mindev option to clip out any device blocks that are too small 167 to see easily. The following command will give a nice dev mode run: 168 169 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -m mem -rtcwake 15 -mindev 1 -dev 170 171 or with a config file 172 173 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -config config/suspend-dev.cfg 174 175 176 Proc Mode Usage 177 _______________ 178 179 Proc mode adds user process info to the timeline. This is done in a manner 180 similar to the bootchart utility, which graphs init processes and their 181 execution as the system boots. This tool option does the same thing but for 182 the period before and after suspend/resume. 183 184 In order to see any process info, there needs to be some delay before or 185 after resume since processes are frozen in suspend_prepare and thawed in 186 resume_complete. The predelay and postdelay args allow you to do this. It 187 can also be useful to run in x2 mode with an x2 delay, this way you can 188 see process activity before and after resume, and in between two 189 successive suspend/resumes. 190 191 The command can be run like this: 192 193 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -m mem -rtcwake 15 -x2 -x2delay 1000 -predelay 1000 -postdelay 1000 -proc 194 195 or with a config file 196 197 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -config config/suspend-proc.cfg 198 199 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 200 | ENDURANCE TESTING | 201 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 202 203 The best way to gauge the health of a system is to run a series of 204 suspend/resumes over an extended period and analyze the behavior. This can be 205 accomplished with sleepgraph's -multi argument. You specify two numbers: the 206 number of tests to run OR the duration in days, hours, or minutes, and the 207 delay in seconds between them. For instance, -multi 20 5: execute 20 tests with 208 a 5 second delay between each, or -multi 24h 0: execute tests over a 24 hour 209 period with no delay between tests. You can include any other options you like 210 to generate the data you want. It's most useful to collect dev mode timelines 211 as the kprobes don't alter the performance much and you get more insight. 212 213 On completion, the output folder contains a series of folders for the 214 individual test data and a set of summary pages in the root. The summary.html 215 file is a tabular list of the tests with relevant info and links. The 216 summary-issue.html and summary-devices.html files include data taken from 217 all tests on kernel issues and device performance. The folder looks like this: 218 219 suspend-xN-{date}-{time}: 220 summary.html 221 summary-issues.html 222 summary-devices.html 223 suspend-{date}-{time} (1) 224 suspend-{date}-{time} (2) 225 ... 226 227 These are the relevant arguments to use for testing: 228 229 -m mode 230 Mode to initiate for suspend e.g. mem, freeze, standby (default: mem). 231 232 -rtcwake t 233 Use rtcwake to autoresume after t seconds (default: 15). 234 235 -gzip (optional) 236 Gzip the trace and dmesg logs to save space. The tool can also read in 237 gzipped logs for processing. This reduces the multitest folder size. 238 239 -dev (optional) 240 Add kernel source calls and threads to the timeline (default: disabled). 241 242 -multi n d 243 Execute n consecutive tests at d seconds intervals. The outputs will be 244 created in a new subdirectory: suspend-xN-{date}-{time}. When the multitest 245 run is done, the -summary command is called automatically to create summary 246 html files for all the data (unless you use -skiphtml). -skiphtml will 247 speed up the testing by not creating timelines or summary html files. You 248 can then run the tool again at a later time with -summary and -genhtml to 249 create the timelines. 250 251 -skiphtml (optional) 252 Run the test and capture the trace logs, but skip the timeline and summary 253 html generation. This can greatly speed up overall testing. You can then 254 copy the data to a faster host machine and run -summary -genhtml to 255 generate the timelines and summary. 256 257 These are the relevant commands to use after testing is complete: 258 259 -summary indir 260 Generate or regenerate the summary for a -multi test run. Creates three 261 files: summary.html, summary-issues.html, and summary-devices.html in the 262 current folder. summary.html is a table of tests with relevant info sorted 263 by kernel/host/mode, and links to the test html files. summary-issues.html 264 is a list of kernel issues found in dmesg from all the tests. 265 summary-devices.html is a list of devices and times from all the tests. 266 267 -genhtml 268 Used with -summary to regenerate any missing html timelines from their 269 dmesg and ftrace logs. This will require a significant amount of time if 270 there are thousands of tests. 271 272 Usage Examples 273 _______________ 274 275 A multitest is initiated like this: 276 277 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -m mem -rtcwake 10 -dev -gzip -multi 2000 0 278 279 or you can skip timeline generation in order to speed things up 280 281 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -m mem -rtcwake 10 -dev -gzip -multi 2000 0 -skiphtml 282 283 The tool will produce an output folder with all the test subfolders inside. 284 Each test subfolder contains the dmesg/ftrace logs and/or the html timeline 285 depending on whether you used the -skiphtml option. The root folder contains 286 the summary.html files. 287 288 The summary for an existing multitest is generated like this: 289 290 %> cd suspend-x2000-{date}-{time} 291 %> sleepgraph.py -summary . 292 293 or if you need to generate the html timelines you can use -genhtml 294 295 %> cd suspend-xN-{date}-{time} 296 %> sleepgraph.py -summary . -genhtml 297 298 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 299 | CONFIGURATION FILES | 300 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 301 302 Since 4.0 we've moved to using config files in lieu of command line options. 303 The config folder contains a collection of typical use cases. 304 There are corresponding configs for other power modes: 305 306 Simple suspend/resume with basic timeline (mem/freeze/standby) 307 config/suspend.cfg 308 config/freeze.cfg 309 config/standby.cfg 310 311 Dev mode suspend/resume with dev timeline (mem/freeze/standby) 312 config/suspend-dev.cfg 313 config/freeze-dev.cfg 314 config/standby-dev.cfg 315 316 Simple suspend/resume with timeline and callgraph (mem/freeze/standby) 317 config/suspend-callgraph.cfg 318 config/freeze-callgraph.cfg 319 config/standby-callgraph.cfg 320 321 Sample proc mode x2 run using mem suspend 322 config/suspend-x2-proc.cfg 323 324 Sample for editing timeline funcs (moves internal functions into config) 325 config/custom-timeline-functions.cfg 326 327 Sample debug config for serio subsystem 328 config/debug-serio-suspend.cfg 329 330 331 Usage Examples 332 ______________ 333 334 Run a simple mem suspend: 335 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -config config/suspend.cfg 336 337 Run a mem suspend with callgraph data: 338 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -config config/suspend-callgraph.cfg 339 340 Run a mem suspend with dev mode detail: 341 %> sudo ./sleepgraph.py -config config/suspend-dev.cfg 342 343 344 Config File Options 345 ___________________ 346 347 [Settings] 348 349 # Verbosity: print verbose messages (def: false) 350 verbose: false 351 352 # Suspend Mode: e.g. standby, mem, freeze, disk (def: mem) 353 mode: mem 354 355 # Output Directory Format: {hostname}, {date}, {time} give current values 356 output-dir: suspend-{hostname}-{date}-{time} 357 358 # Automatic Wakeup: use rtcwake to wakeup after X seconds (def: infinity) 359 rtcwake: 15 360 361 # Add Logs: add the dmesg and ftrace log to the html output (def: false) 362 addlogs: false 363 364 # Sus/Res Gap: insert a gap between sus & res in the timeline (def: false) 365 srgap: false 366 367 # Custom Command: Command to execute in lieu of suspend (def: "") 368 command: echo mem > /sys/power/state 369 370 # Proc mode: graph user processes and cpu usage in the timeline (def: false) 371 proc: false 372 373 # Dev mode: graph source functions in the timeline (def: false) 374 dev: false 375 376 # Suspend/Resume x2: run 2 suspend/resumes back to back (def: false) 377 x2: false 378 379 # x2 Suspend Delay: time delay between the two test runs in ms (def: 0 ms) 380 x2delay: 0 381 382 # Pre Suspend Delay: nclude an N ms delay before (1st) suspend (def: 0 ms) 383 predelay: 0 384 385 # Post Resume Delay: include an N ms delay after (last) resume (def: 0 ms) 386 postdelay: 0 387 388 # Min Device Length: graph only dev callbacks longer than min (def: 0.001 ms) 389 mindev: 0.001 390 391 # Callgraph: gather ftrace callgraph data on all timeline events (def: false) 392 callgraph: false 393 394 # Expand Callgraph: pre-expand the callgraph treeviews in html (def: false) 395 expandcg: false 396 397 # Min Callgraph Length: show callgraphs only if longer than min (def: 1 ms) 398 mincg: 1 399 400 # Timestamp Precision: number of sig digits in timestamps (0:S, [3:ms], 6:us) 401 timeprec: 3 402 403 # Device Filter: show only devs whose name/driver includes one of these strings 404 devicefilter: _cpu_up,_cpu_down,i915,usb 405 406 # Override default timeline entries: 407 # Do not use the internal default functions for timeline entries (def: false) 408 # Set this to true if you intend to only use the ones defined in the config 409 override-timeline-functions: true 410 411 # Override default dev timeline entries: 412 # Do not use the internal default functions for dev timeline entries (def: false) 413 # Set this to true if you intend to only use the ones defined in the config 414 override-dev-timeline-functions: true 415 416 # Call Loop Max Gap (dev mode only) 417 # merge loops of the same call if each is less than maxgap apart (def: 100us) 418 callloop-maxgap: 0.0001 419 420 # Call Loop Max Length (dev mode only) 421 # merge loops of the same call if each is less than maxlen in length (def: 5ms) 422 callloop-maxlen: 0.005 423 424 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 425 | CUSTOM TIMELINE ENTRIES | 426 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 427 428 Adding or Editing Timeline Functions 429 ____________________________________ 430 431 The tool uses an array of function names to fill out empty spaces in the 432 timeline where device callbacks don't appear. For instance, in suspend_prepare 433 the tool adds the sys_sync and freeze_processes calls as virtual device blocks 434 in the timeline to show you where the time is going. These calls should fill 435 the timeline with contiguous data so that most kernel execution is covered. 436 437 It is possible to add new function calls to the timeline by adding them to 438 the config. It's also possible to copy the internal timeline functions into 439 the config so that you can override and edit them. Place them in the 440 timeline_functions_ARCH section with the name of your architecture appended. 441 i.e. for x86_64: [timeline_functions_x86_64] 442 443 Use the override-timeline-functions option if you only want to use your 444 custom calls, or leave it false to append them to the internal ones. 445 446 This section includes a list of functions (set using kprobes) which use both 447 symbol data and function arg data. The args are pulled directly from the 448 stack using this architecture's registers and stack formatting. Each entry 449 can include up to four pieces of info: The function name, a format string, 450 an argument list, and a color. But only a function name is required. 451 452 For a full example config, see config/custom-timeline-functions.cfg. It pulls 453 all the internal timeline functions into the config and allows you to edit 454 them. 455 456 Entry format: 457 458 function: format{fn_arg1}_{fn_arg2} fn_arg1 fn_arg2 ... [color=purple] 459 460 Required Arguments: 461 462 function: The symbol name for the function you want probed, this is the 463 minimum required for an entry, it will show up as the function 464 name with no arguments. 465 466 example: _cpu_up: 467 468 Optional Arguments: 469 470 format: The format to display the data on the timeline in. Use braces to 471 enclose the arg names. 472 473 example: CPU_ON[{cpu}] 474 475 color: The color of the entry block in the timeline. The default color is 476 transparent, so the entry shares the phase color. The color is an 477 html color string, either a word, or an RGB. 478 479 example: [color=#CC00CC] 480 481 arglist: A list of arguments from registers/stack addresses. See URL: 482 https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/trace/kprobetrace.txt 483 484 example: cpu=%di:s32 485 486 Here is a full example entry. It displays cpu resume calls in the timeline 487 in orange. They will appear as CPU_ON[0], CPU_ON[1], etc. 488 489 [timeline_functions_x86_64] 490 _cpu_up: CPU_ON[{cpu}] cpu=%di:s32 [color=orange] 491 492 493 Adding or Editing Dev Mode Timeline Source Functions 494 ____________________________________________________ 495 496 In dev mode, the tool uses an array of function names to monitor source 497 execution within the timeline entries. 498 499 The function calls are displayed inside the main device/call blocks in the 500 timeline. However, if a function call is not within a main timeline event, 501 it will spawn an entirely new event named after the caller's kernel thread. 502 These asynchronous kernel threads will populate in a separate section 503 beneath the main device/call section. 504 505 The tool has a set of hard coded calls which focus on the most common use 506 cases: msleep, udelay, schedule_timeout, mutex_lock_slowpath, etc. These are 507 the functions that add a hardcoded time delay to the suspend/resume path. 508 The tool also includes some common functions native to important 509 subsystems: ata, i915, and ACPI, etc. 510 511 It is possible to add new function calls to the dev timeline by adding them 512 to the config. It's also possible to copy the internal dev timeline 513 functions into the config so that you can override and edit them. Place them 514 in the dev_timeline_functions_ARCH section with the name of your architecture 515 appended. i.e. for x86_64: [dev_timeline_functions_x86_64] 516 517 Use the override-dev-timeline-functions option if you only want to use your 518 custom calls, or leave it false to append them to the internal ones. 519 520 The format is the same as the timeline_functions_x86_64 section. It's a 521 list of functions (set using kprobes) which use both symbol data and function 522 arg data. The args are pulled directly from the stack using this 523 architecture's registers and stack formatting. Each entry can include up 524 to four pieces of info: The function name, a format string, an argument list, 525 and a color. But only the function name is required. 526 527 For a full example config, see config/custom-timeline-functions.cfg. It pulls 528 all the internal dev timeline functions into the config and allows you to edit 529 them. 530 531 Here is a full example entry. It displays the ATA port reset calls as 532 ataN_port_reset in the timeline. This is where most of the SATA disk resume 533 time goes, so it can be helpful to see the low level call. 534 535 [dev_timeline_functions_x86_64] 536 ata_eh_recover: ata{port}_port_reset port=+36(%di):s32 [color=#CC00CC] 537 538 539 Verifying your custom functions 540 _______________________________ 541 542 Once you have a set of functions (kprobes) defined, it can be useful to 543 perform a quick check to see if you formatted them correctly and if the system 544 actually supports them. To do this, run the tool with your config file 545 and the -status option. The tool will go through all the kprobes (both 546 custom and internal if you haven't overridden them) and actually attempts 547 to set them in ftrace. It will then print out success or fail for you. 548 549 Note that kprobes which don't actually exist in the kernel won't stop the 550 tool, they just wont show up. 551 552 For example: 553 554 sudo ./sleepgraph.py -config config/custom-timeline-functions.cfg -status 555 Checking this system (myhostname)... 556 have root access: YES 557 is sysfs mounted: YES 558 is "mem" a valid power mode: YES 559 is ftrace supported: YES 560 are kprobes supported: YES 561 timeline data source: FTRACE (all trace events found) 562 is rtcwake supported: YES 563 verifying timeline kprobes work: 564 _cpu_down: YES 565 _cpu_up: YES 566 acpi_pm_finish: YES 567 acpi_pm_prepare: YES 568 freeze_kernel_threads: YES 569 freeze_processes: YES 570 sys_sync: YES 571 thaw_processes: YES 572 verifying dev kprobes work: 573 __const_udelay: YES 574 __mutex_lock_slowpath: YES 575 acpi_os_stall: YES 576 acpi_ps_parse_aml: YES 577 intel_opregion_init: NO 578 intel_opregion_register: NO 579 intel_opregion_setup: NO 580 msleep: YES 581 schedule_timeout: YES 582 schedule_timeout_uninterruptible: YES 583 usleep_range: YES 584 585 586 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 587 | TESTING ON CONSUMER LINUX OPERATING SYSTEMS | 588 ------------------------------------------------------------------ 589 590 Android 591 _______ 592 593 The easiest way to execute on an android device is to run the android.sh 594 script on the device, then pull the ftrace log back to the host and run 595 sleepgraph.py on it. 596 597 Here are the steps: 598 599 [download and install the tool on the device] 600 601 host%> wget https://raw.githubusercontent.com/intel/pm-graph/master/tools/android.sh 602 host%> adb connect 192.168.1.6 603 host%> adb root 604 # push the script to a writeable location 605 host%> adb push android.sh /sdcard/ 606 607 [check whether the tool will run on your device] 608 609 host%> adb shell 610 dev%> cd /sdcard 611 dev%> sh android.sh status 612 host : asus_t100 613 kernel : 3.14.0-i386-dirty 614 modes : freeze mem 615 rtcwake : supported 616 ftrace : supported 617 trace events { 618 suspend_resume: found 619 device_pm_callback_end: found 620 device_pm_callback_start: found 621 } 622 # the above is what you see on a system that's properly patched 623 624 [execute the suspend] 625 626 # NOTE: The suspend will only work if the screen isn't timed out, 627 # so you have to press some keys first to wake it up b4 suspend) 628 dev%> sh android.sh suspend mem 629 ------------------------------------ 630 Suspend/Resume timing test initiated 631 ------------------------------------ 632 hostname : asus_t100 633 kernel : 3.14.0-i386-dirty 634 mode : mem 635 ftrace out : /mnt/shell/emulated/0/ftrace.txt 636 dmesg out : /mnt/shell/emulated/0/dmesg.txt 637 log file : /mnt/shell/emulated/0/log.txt 638 ------------------------------------ 639 INITIALIZING FTRACE........DONE 640 STARTING FTRACE 641 SUSPEND START @ 21:24:02 (rtcwake in 10 seconds) 642 <adb connection will now terminate> 643 644 [retrieve the data from the device] 645 646 # I find that you have to actually kill the adb process and 647 # reconnect sometimes in order for the connection to work post-suspend 648 host%> adb connect 192.168.1.6 649 # (required) get the ftrace data, this is the most important piece 650 host%> adb pull /sdcard/ftrace.txt 651 # (optional) get the dmesg data, this is for debugging 652 host%> adb pull /sdcard/dmesg.txt 653 # (optional) get the log, which just lists some test times for comparison 654 host%> adb pull /sdcard/log.txt 655 656 [create an output html file using sleepgraph.py] 657 658 host%> sleepgraph.py -ftrace ftrace.txt 659 660 You should now have an output.html with the android data, enjoy!
Linux® is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds in the United States and other countries.
TOMOYO® is a registered trademark of NTT DATA CORPORATION.